Farm Transparency International Ltd v The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd [2026] HCA 42
Key takeaways
- If footage is obtained by trespass, a Court can order the trespasser to delete or destroy it, even after the trespass has ended, if damages are inadequate to repair the consequences
- A constructive trust over the trespasser’s copyright in unlawfully obtained footage is available in principle, but it was inappropriate in this case
- Courts should grant the minimum relief needed to do justice. Remedies affecting third parties, including regulators and media organisations, require careful justification and ordinarily their participation in the proceedings
- Public interest and freedom of communication considerations weigh heavily against orders that indirectly restrain publication by third parties.
Background
Game Meats operates an export-licensed abattoir. On seven occasions in early 2024, representatives of animal welfare charity Farm Transparency entered its premises at night and installed hidden cameras.
Farm Transparency used the recordings to create a 14-minute film, which it provided to the Commonwealth Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry with a request that the abattoir’s licence be suspended, and later to Channel Seven. Channel Seven reported on the footage but did not broadcast it. Farm Transparency also briefly published the film online before removing it following an interlocutory injunction.
At trial, Snaden J upheld Game Meats’ trespass claim and awarded $30,000 in general damages and $100,000 in exemplary damages, but refused an injunction, deletion order and constructive trust.
The Full Federal Court went further, declaring that Farm Transparency held copyright in the images on constructive trust for Game Meats. It also ordered an assignment of the copyright, deletion of the footage, and restrictions on its publication.
The High Court's decision
The High Court allowed Farm Transparency’s appeal in part. It set aside the constructive trust and most of the Full Court’s orders but upheld, and expanded, the order requiring Farm Transparency to delete the images.
Injunctions can repair the consequences of a completed trespass
The Court confirmed that there is no rule preventing a mandatory injunction if the wrong was completed before proceedings began. A ‘restorative’ mandatory injunction may be ordered to correct the consequences of a tort, and not only the wrongful act itself, if damages are inadequate. The reference in a previous case of Patrick Stevedores to damage that is ‘extreme, or at all events ‘very serious’ was explained as reflecting the ordinary inquiry into whether damages are adequate, not a heightened threshold of proof.
Damages were not enough
The damages awarded at trial compensated Game Meats for the trespasses but not the consequences of future publication. Because Farm Transparency intended to continue using the footage to harm Game Meats’ business, damages alone were inadequate. A deletion order was therefore an appropriate remedy.
A constructive trust was available, but not appropriate
Drawing on observations in the landmark 2001 High Court decision of Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats, the Court accepted that a constructive trust over copyright in images created through trespass could be available in principle. However, it should not have been imposed here, for several reasons:
- A constructive trust should not be imposed if other orders can do full justice, and the Full Court had not first considered whether an injunction against Farm Transparency would suffice
- The real value of the trust to Game Meats was the ability to sue third parties for copyright infringement, including the Commonwealth and Channel Seven, none of whom had been joined to the proceedings
- Such a remedy risked curtailing freedom of communication on political and governmental matters and inviting a multiplicity of further proceedings
- The interaction with the new statutory tort for serious invasions of privacy in Schedule 2 to the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth), and with the regulatory role of the Department, had not been properly explored.
The plurality also cautioned against treating the trust as one arising automatically on the creation of the footage. Describing a trespasser’s conduct as ‘unconscionable’ is not, by itself, a principled basis for a constructive trust, and analogies with theft, fraud and mistaken payment cases did not fit, despite the Full Court’s lengthy consideration of those issues.
The final orders
Farm Transparency must immediately and permanently delete or destroy all images obtained from the cameras, including any copies that come into its possession in future, and provide affidavits confirming deletion.
Given the mixed outcome of the appeal, each party bears its own costs in the High Court, and the costs of the earlier hearings were remitted to the Full Court.
Notably, the orders do not prevent the Department or Channel Seven from using footage already in their possession. Nor do they stop Farm Transparency from making submissions to the regulator or commenting publicly on the abattoir’s operations.
What this means for organisations
Organisations and businesses whose premises are targeted
The decision extends beyond animal welfare activism. Increasing access to body cameras, smart glasses and other surveillance devices creates risk for government, mining, environmental, defence, financial services and other organisations likely to attract advocacy, activism or media attention.
For organisations whose premises are targeted:
- Act quickly. Urgent interlocutory relief can limit dissemination and strengthen an argument that damages alone are inadequate
- Expect relief to focus on the wrongdoer. Deletion is more readily available than proprietary remedies designed to control third party use of footage obtained
- Consider third parties early. If restrictions are sought to be imposed on any media organisation or other recipient, they may need to be joined to the proceedings, with public interest and freedom of expression arguments addressed
- Use interlocutory tools. Discovery and interrogatories can help establish who received the footage before trial, but identification of recipients is not a matter which should be left to final orders.
For advocacy and activist groups, media organisations, regulators and other recipients:
- Trespass to obtain footage carries real consequences: substantial exemplary damages and Court-ordered destruction of any material obtained
- Remedies against the person who obtained footage by trespass will not ordinarily bind recipients who were not parties to the proceedings
- Footage already provided to regulators is unlikely to be affected by orders made against the trespasser, but further publication by the trespasser itself may be prevented.
- The High Court’s emphasis on freedom of communication and the public interest provides meaningful protection against attempts to restrain publication through proprietary claims over copyright
- Recipients should nonetheless take advice on any other potential exposure, including under the statutory tort for serious invasion of privacy.
How we can help
Moray & Agnew advises businesses and other clients on urgent injunctive relief, trespass, privacy, copyright, and the management of sensitive footage and information. We are one of the few firms that has experience in litigating a claim for serious invasion of privacy. We also have experience in helping clients manage the legal and reputational risks arising from sensitive publications and disclosures.
If you would like to discuss how this decision affects your organisation, please contact us.