Masters v Mitchell Shire Council (No 2) [2026] VSC 598
A motorcyclist who suffered serious injuries on a rural road has failed in his claim against Mitchell Shire Council. On 16 September 2026, Justice Keogh of the Supreme Court of Victoria held that Mr Masters had not established that Mitchell Shire Council was liable for the accident and his injuries, and that the proceeding be dismissed. With the State of Victoria’s roads currently a hot topic of conversation, this decision is a timely reminder that a rough road does not automatically mean a liable Council. Where a Council has a clear Road Management Plan (‘RMP’) and can prove it was followed, the Road Management Act 2004 (Vic) (‘Road Management Act’) provides strong protection. Moray & Agnew acted for Mitchell Shire Council in this successful defence at trial. The plaintiff may seek leave to appeal, and we continue to monitor this.
Key takeaways
- Your RMP is your shield. Clear standards in an RMP, and evidence to prove those standards were met, place a Council in a strong position to defend a claim.
- Inspect on time, every time. Proactive RMP inspections were completed as required and were not seriously challenged at trial.
- Evidence of inspections wins cases. Inspection records and evidence at trial from trained inspectors are important aspects of a defence.
- Actual knowledge means knowledge of the particular risk. The Court held that the relevant risk had to relate to the applicable RMP standard (a heave of more than 60 mm), and the evidence relied on (a resident’s alleged 2020 report, 2018 condition inspection photographs and the 2021–2022 inspections) did not establish actual knowledge of that risk.
- Notify early. Prompt notification (consistent with section 115 of the Road Management Act) allows information to be gathered and evidence preserved at the outset.
What happened?
On Christmas Day 2022, Mr Masters fell off his motorcycle on a curve on Reedy Creek Road, Tyaak. He suffered a closed head injury and spinal injuries and had no reliable memory of the accident. There were no eyewitnesses. He alleged the crash was caused by a ‘heave’ (a raised section of road surface), either because he lost control avoiding it or riding over it, or (alternatively) because avoiding it caused him to ride over a nearby pothole, and that Mitchell Shire Council had breached its statutory duty under the Road Management Act and its duty of care at common law. Mitchell Shire Council was not told about the accident until March 2024, more than 14 months later, when it received correspondence from Mr Masters’ solicitors.
Why did the claim fail?
The claim failed on causation and on breach. The Court also found that the statutory defences would have been available had it been necessary.
- Causation was not proven. The experts accepted there were possible explanations for the crash that had nothing to do with the road, such as the rider’s line or speed through the curve. The experts could not say that the heave was the more likely cause. Justice Keogh was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the heave caused the accident.
- The defect was not shown to exceed the intervention level. Mitchell Shire Council’s 2021 RMP set an intervention level of greater than 60 mm for heaves and required inspections twice a year. Mr Masters could not prove the heave was greater than 60 mm at the time the inspections were performed by Council in 2021 and 2022, or at the time of the accident. Mr Masters’ attempt to also rely on an earlier 2017 RMP was also rejected.
- The RMP was followed. Mitchell Shire Council established that it completed the inspections required by the 2021 RMP, which were carried out by trained inspectors whose evidence was effectively unchallenged. The Court found that, had it been necessary, the statutory defences under sections 103 and 105 of the Road Management Act would have been available to Mitchell Shire Council.
- No actual knowledge. The Court rejected the argument that Mitchell Shire Council had actual knowledge of the particular risk posed by the heave, for the purpose of section 102 of the Road Management Act. Evidence from a local resident witness about measurements he said he reported to the Council in 2020 was rejected.
- No notice of accident. Section 115 of the Road Management Act requires a person proposing to make a claim to give the road authority written notice of the incident within 30 days. Mr Masters did not. As a result, Mitchell Shire Council lost the chance to assess the condition of the curve, and to take photographs and measurements, soon after the crash. Taking that failure into account under subsection 115(4), the Court said that it reinforced the findings about the size of the heave (namely, that it was not shown to exceed the intervention level).
What does this mean for Councils?
This decision confirms that the Road Management Act allows Councils to set their own standards via their RMP, and that compliance with those standards is the key to the statutory defences. It also shows that where a Council can prove it followed its RMP, a plaintiff may find it difficult to establish common law negligence by pointing to informal practices or alleged lower standards. The Court rejected Mr Masters’ submissions that Mitchell Shire Council was negligent at common law for failing to comply with alleged ‘policies’ to remedy defects below the RMP intervention level and to erect warning signs, finding that those ‘policies’ were not established and that the inspections were not shown to be negligent. Councils should:
- Ensure inspections are completed on schedule and clearly recorded
- Ensure inspectors consistently apply the same inspection methods and keep relevant records
- Be careful with informal practices. The Court found that the evidence did not establish that an informal practice of recording some defects below intervention levels was a Council policy, but informal practices that go beyond the RMP can invite arguments (as were run here, relying on Kennedy v Shire of Campaspe [2015] VSCA 215) that a higher standard applies
- Carefully consider Council’s response to section 115 notices and complaints about road defects generally
- Locate and disclose all relevant documents (including condition, proactive and reactive inspection data) as early as possible in a claim.
Conclusion
This judgment of the Supreme Court of Victoria is an important outcome for Victorian Councils. It demonstrates an RMP which is consistently followed, with clear methods and systems, is likely to be a Council’s best defence to claims arising out of the inspection, maintenance and/or repair of a road.